18 November 2026

T 2034/22 - The Belgian State as opponent

Key points

  • The indication of the opponent is "ÉTAT BELGE, représenté par le Ministre de la Sécurité et de l'Intérieur".
  • The opponent also appointed a professional representative and filed an authorisation together with the Notice of opposition.
  • The proprietor objects that the opposition is inadmissible because the opponent was not validly represented by le Ministre de la Sécurité et de l'Intérieur, essentially on the ground that, under Belgian constitutional/administrative law, another minister is in charge of IP rights.
  • "The admissibility of an opposition against a patent under the European Patent Convention is to be examined with respect to the appropriate legal frame­work, which is the European Patent Convention, in particular Article 99(1) EPC. The right to bring opposition proceedings and to take part in opposition and appeal proceedings is indeed a matter of procedural law governed by the EPC (G 1/13, point 5.3 of the Reasons with reference to G 3/97, point 2.1 of the Reasons). The status of a legal person as such, i.e. whether it has capacity to sue or be sued, is by contrast a matter of national law. In the current case, it does not appear to be disputed that the conditions laid down in the EPC are met."
    •  I don't know the relevance of "The status of a legal person as such, i.e. whether it has capacity to sue or be sued, is by contrast a matter of national law", other than that an entity may be given the status of 'legal person' under national law. 
  • " What is in fact disputed by the appellant is the capacity of the then Minister of the Interior and Security to file a notice of opposition and bring opposition proceedings before the European Patent Office, in light of the allocation of competences within the Belgian state, which comprises a federal authority and the federated entities. Hence, it has to be established whether the Minister of the Interior and Security had the legal capacity to act on behalf of the Belgian state at the time the notice of opposition was filed."
  • Follows a detailed analysis of Belgian law.
  • "It therefore follows from Belgian national law and case law that the Ministry of the Interior and Security has the legal capacity to act on behalf of the Belgian state, including with regard to patent proceedings, in areas falling within its assigned jurisdiction, which include security alerts, the protection of the population and institutions in Belgium, the organisation of emergency planning, crisis management at the national level, and support for emergency planning at the provincial and local levels."
  • " For these reasons, the opposition filed on behalf of the Belgian State is admissible."
    • The issue may be akin to whether an authorisation is signed by the correct company officer in cases where a company is a party to the proceedings. For instance, if an assistant director signs a PoA, is that sufficient? This can be examined with reference to the company's by-laws. I don't know exactly how detailed the EPO's examination is on this. 
    • It may help to omit the phrase "représenté par le Ministre de la Sécurité et de l'Intérieur" from the opponent's "name". The opponent (the Belgian State) was represented by a European patent attorney in the procedure. 
EPO 
The link to the decision is provided after the jump.

No comments:

Post a Comment

Do not use hyperlinks in comment text or user name. Comments are welcome, even though they are strictly moderated (no politics). Moderation can take some time.