16 November 2026

T 1089/26 - Appeal decision in 3 months

Key points

  • SoG filed 08.07.2026. Decision issued 30.09.2026.
  • The Examining Division issued a Form 2061 refusal (that referred to three earlier Communications)
  • "In its letter of 12 February 2026, the applicant submitted detailed arguments directed to the objections on which the examining division subsequently based the refusal. These submissions concerned, in particular, the objection under Article 84 EPC and the objection of lack of inventive step. They were thus relevant to the issues decisive for the refusal. 
  • 1.3 The examining division did not consider these arguments before taking its decision. In fact, the decision expressly states, after listing the communications of 31 March 2021, 8 April 2022 and 11 June 2025, that the applicant had filed "no comments or amendments in reply to the latest communication". This statement is factually incorrect. The applicant's letter of 12 February 2026 constituted a detailed response to the communication of 11 June 2025 accompanying the summons. 
  • 1.4 The applicant was consequently deprived of its right to have its relevant arguments considered before an adverse decision was taken."
  • Apparently, there is still no robust quality control implemented on Form 2061. Does anyone know if a Director (Team Manager) must sign off on the form?
EPO 
The link to the decision is provided after the jump.


No comments:

Post a Comment

Do not use hyperlinks in comment text or user name. Comments are welcome, even though they are strictly moderated (no politics). Moderation can take some time.