T 0700/25 - Appealing the grant, filing a div

Key points

• A patent is granted. The proprietor appeals against the grant and files a divisional application. The EPO deletes the mention of the grant (that is to say, publishes a new statement in the Bulletin that the first mention of the grant is deleted). The proprietor withdraws the appeal before filing the Statement of grounds. The proprietor requests the refund of the appeal fee, and requests "that the application go back to its granted state, and that a communication informing them of the new date of the mention of the grant be issued"
• The Board sees an issue: "the appeal fee is also reimbursed if it was paid for no valid reason, e.g. if the appeal is deemed not filed (see G 1/18 ). This second basis for reimbursement takes precedence over the first [i.e., Rule 103(10(b) EPC], because ... . Therefore, preliminary to the reimbursement of the appeal fee under Rule 103(1)(b) EPC, the Board has to assess whether an appeal was validly filed or not."
• The actual question is, of course, whether the divisional application was validly filed.
• "The Board is of the view that an appeal of the Examining Division's decision to grant a patent, in order that the application again become "pending", within the meaning of Rule 36(1) EPC, is manifestly inadmissible and does not provide a valid reason for the payment of the appeal fee. The Board follows, in this regard, the rationale of decision J 28/03, and not that of decision J 1/24. In the Board's view, there is no basis for the appellant's contention that the more recent of the two decisions necessarily takes precedence. As will be explained below, the Board's view is also in line with the rationale of decisions G 2/19 and G 1/09"
• "One of the two conditions giving rise to an entitlement to appeal is that the appellant is adversely affected by the contested decision. However, an applicant is not adversely affected by a decision to grant that accedes to the applicant's requests. Therefore, such an applicant is not entitled under Article 107, first sentence, EPC to appeal such a decision."
• "Contrary to decision J 1/24, an appeal of a decision to grant cannot be assumed validly to exist. An application proceeds to grant only on condition that the applicant has agreed to the text, under Article 113(2) EPC (Rule 71a(1) EPC; [...]). Consequently, an applicant appealing a decision to grant must justify their entitlement to appeal and set out why that decision is not in conformity with the applicant's requests or why it otherwise negatively affects them. Therefore, there is a presumption, that an applicant is not entitled under Article 107, first sentence, EPC to appeal a decision to grant, if their appeal is withdrawn before the filing of any statement of grounds of appeal, since no reasons have been given justifying their entitlement to appeal. Moreover, the appeal being withdrawn, the decision to grant becomes effective. Therefore, a withdrawal of an appeal of the decision to grant, before the filing of a statement of grounds of appeal, confirms that the appeal was filed by an applicant not entitled to appeal under Article 107, second sentence, EPC. Hence, such an appeal is manifestly inadmissible and filed without legitimate reason.
• "The filing of an appeal of a decision to grant a patent based on the earlier application attempts to circumvent the deliberate lack of a legal remedy for restoring the pending status within the meaning of Rule 36(1) EPC. Such an appeal is a clearly inadmissible means of redress and has no suspensive effect (G 2/19, point 6)."
  • Evidently, the Board used the opportunity to opine on the validity of the divisional application lest the Examining Division happily grant it.
  • The Boards may have to decide in the near future on he modified case wherein the applicant files a Statement of grounds and shortly thereafter withdraws the appeal.
  • The Board departs from J 1/24 ,  see above.'

EPO 

The link to the decision is provided after the jump.

https://www.epo.org/en/boards-of-appeal/decisions/t250700eu1